Review: a Performance by Sarah Connolly and Tenebrae

by Cordelia Hobbs



Receiving last minute tickets to hear world renowned choir Tenebrae perform at Wigmore Hall was a dream. Especially considering that they were performing my favourite choral piece, Herbert Howells’ ‘Take Him Earth For Cherishing’. The reason I love this piece so much is the compelling words but what makes it momentous is its motivation. Although the piece was commissioned for J.F. Kennedy’s funeral, Howells’ real stimulus was the sudden death of his own son, Michael who died whilst the family was on holiday by contracting polio aged nine, dying three days later. This was in 1935, and afterwards, Howells found he was unable to work for a period of time. The piece is filled with lush, uplifting and mysterious chords and harmony that endeavor to portray the link between paradise and Earth. Earth is personified and the piece goes through many emotional turns. The music gains some clarity in the fugal section beginning ‘once again’ and the most moving and majestic harmony is set to the words “Take, O take him, mighty leader,”  with the heart warming quirk of modulating back to the home key on the words “return again” making for a effulgent moment of word painting. Furthermore, Howells was intimately intertwined with the this poem and the poetry of Prudentius in general, writing in his diary in May of 1958, ‘Rain and Gloom. But the rain turned away with a sheer beauty of light. Prudentius’. When looking at the text, I can understand why:


Take him, earth, for cherishing,
to thy tender breast receive him.
Body of a man I bring thee,
noble even in its ruin.

Once was this a spirit’s dwelling,
by the breath of God created.
High the heart that here was beating,
Christ the prince of all its living.

Guard him well, the dead I give thee,
not unmindful of his creature
shall he ask it: he who made it
symbol of his mystery.

Comes the hour God hath appointed
to fulfil the hope of men,
then must thou, in very fashion,
what I give, return again.


Not though ancient time decaying
wear away these bones to sand,
ashes that a man might measure
in the hollow of his hand:

Not though wandering winds and idle,
drifting through the empty sky,
scatter dust was nerve and sinew,
is it given to man to die.

Once again the shining road
leads to ample Paradise;
open are the woods again,
that the serpent lost for men

Take, O take him, mighty leader,
take again thy servant’s soul.
Grave his name, and pour the fragrant
balm upon the icy stone.


The text comes from a translation by Helen Wadell of a Latin poem by Prudentius (AD 348–413). Being the nerd I am for this piece, I was thrilled to get to see Howells’ own annotated copy of this poem last year in all its aged beauty. Singing this piece brings goosebumps to the surface my skin and it was a deeply emotional experience hearing it sung borderline perfectly. In addition to Tenebrae, I listened to renowned mezzo-soprano Dame Sarah Connolly sing war songs. I don’t often like to comment on the qualities of clothing when reflecting on a concert, however it has to be said that I appreciated that Dame Connolly did not look like an archetypal mezzo soprano. She reminded me of a beautiful and dignified tropical bird in a crushed velvet nehru jacket with very short, platinum blonde, swept back hair. Although an odd comment, granted, it reminded me that classical music is not set in the traditional and a concert didn’t have to fit a paradigm of look or atmosphere. Her dark timbre was infused with sorrow as she sang Parry’s Songs of Farewell and some Ivor Gurney too. Her voice and vibrato gave a sonorous and nuanced quality to the music with a particularly aureate line “I’m homesick for my hills again” from In Flanders by Ivor Gurney. Another line that jumped out at me too was “But I cherish my freedom” which was set to soaring high notes making it extremely emotive. Both Tenebrae and Connolly came together to perform Judith Bingham’s A Walk with Ivor Gurney. There is something worth noting when hearing a professional choir accompany an expressive soloist, there is a delicacy to the accompaniment and an awareness of blend that particularly Tenebrae has. Overall, the experience was one I won’t forget for a long time and I urge you to listen to Howells’ music as it truly is the best.






Comments